Portfolio Case Study Year 2019–2021 Theme Early Child Development Approach Common Elements

Nurturing Care for Early Child Development

Using the common elements approach to develop an integrated and scalable intervention for at-risk mothers and children in Pakistan. The project integrated evidence-based components addressing early stimulation, responsive feeding, and perinatal depression, and developed an online training platform for non-specialists to enable scalable delivery.

2019–2021Implementation period
OnlineTraining platform for non-specialists
>250Mother–infant dyads (RCT follow-up 12 months)
IntegratedECD + Nutrition + Maternal mental health
01 Collaborators

Partners

  • World Health Organization (WHO), Geneva
  • University of Liverpool, UK
  • Human Development Research Foundation (HDRF), Pakistan

Why it mattered

Early child development and infant nutrition are global priorities. Scalable interventions that integrate key theoretical constructs influencing ECD and overcome implementation barriers are limited. The common elements approach offers a pathway to create integrated, scalable interventions to improve health, well-being, and future potential of populations in low-resource settings.

02 Need (Problem)

The challenge in South Asia

In South Asia, 35–45% of children are undernourished and over 40 million lag behind in their cognitive and socioemotional development. Millions of children in low-resource settings are at high risk of poor development due to undernutrition, inadequate stimulation, and maternal depression. Although evidence-based interventions exist, they are often delivered as separate, overlapping packages through disjointed systems—creating barriers for scale-up.

03 Innovations

1) Integrated intervention (Common Elements)

A single integrated package was developed using a common elements approach—combining evidence-based elements from packages addressing early stimulation, responsive feeding, and perinatal depression.

2) Online training platform

An online training platform was developed to train non-specialists—including community health workers and caregivers—to deliver the intervention at scale.

04 Core intervention components

What the integrated package covered

Maternal Psychological Well-being

  • Family support during pregnancy, childbirth, and breastfeeding
  • Behavioral activation and problem solving
  • Praise and positive reinforcement of desired behaviors
  • Engaging family and improving social support

Child Development

  • Improving maternal sensitivity and responsiveness towards infants
  • Knowledge and resources for pleasurable, responsive play activity

Nutrition

  • Psychoeducation and behavior change on infant nutrition and feeding
  • Responsive feeding
  • Early initiation of breastfeeding
  • Exclusive breastfeeding for six months

Scalability focus

  • Common elements approach to integrate overlapping packages
  • Training non-specialists through an online platform
  • Designed for low-resource delivery pathways
Common elements approach: a method to identify and combine effective components across different evidence-based packages into a single, coherent intervention.
05 Implementation & Evaluation

Where it was implemented

The Nurturing Care Intervention was implemented in a rural sub-district of Rawalpindi, in close collaboration with government programmes.

  • Government collaboration for feasibility and integration
  • Non-specialist delivery supported through training
  • Designed for scale-up through practical implementation pathways

Evaluation design & outcomes

Evaluated through an individual randomized controlled trial involving over 250 mother–infant dyads followed up over 12 months. Outcomes included caregiver–child interaction, infant development, quality of the home environment, maternal distress, social support, and quality of life.

  • Caregiver–child interaction
  • Infant development
  • Home environment quality
  • Maternal distress & social support
  • Quality of life
06 HAT portfolio

Health Applications of Technology (HAT) supports scalable health and mental health programmes by translating evidence-informed interventions into practical digital systems—enabling training at scale, strengthening delivery workflows, and improving implementation feasibility in low-resource settings.

Online training platforms Digital learning UX Common elements packaging Non-specialist enablement Low-resource implementation RCT-ready workflows